radiation.space
Wiki contents

Validation

Comparison of the models with measurements not used in their fitting.

Method

The tables below are generated by a script in the Python reference engine and included without editing. Rows marked as fit anchors were used to set model parameters and are not independent tests; all other rows are independent.

Unresolved discrepancies:

Figures

GCR proton flux at 1 AU compared with AMS-02 (2011 to 2013). Blue: φ from neutron monitors; orange: φ refit to 670 MV. Lower panel: model/measurement.
GCR proton flux at 1 AU compared with AMS-02 (2011 to 2013). Blue: φ from neutron monitors; orange: φ refit to 670 MV. Lower panel: model/measurement.
Radial dependence of interplanetary components, normalized to 1 AU. SEP flux is held at its 1 AU value beyond 1 AU.
Radial dependence of interplanetary components, normalized to 1 AU. SEP flux is held at its 1 AU value beyond 1 AU.

Results

Model values against published measurements. Sources are listed in the bibliography of this repository.

GCR protons vs AMS-02 2011-2013

R (GV)AMSmodel (Usoskin phi)ratiomodel (phi=670)ratio
1.08626.9847.31.35690.41.10
1.61605.9757.51.25645.11.06
2.82335.9376.91.12339.31.01
4.65143.8142.90.99133.50.93
9.6727.2425.540.9424.670.91
20.283.8943.7310.963.6680.94
43.470.47160.47271.000.46890.99
96.440.050260.052241.040.052051.04
963.778.571e-058.325e-050.978.322e-050.97

SEP event fluences: Band-fit model vs GOES (cm^-2)

eventmodel >10GOES >10ratiomodel >30GOES >30ratio
sep2000_jul142.3e+101.65e+101.393.02e+094.31e+090.70
sep2001_nov041.86e+101.52e+101.232.42e+093.4e+090.71
sep2003_oct281.51e+101.17e+101.292.12e+093.07e+090.69
sep2005_jan208.09e+088.27e+080.983.3e+084.1e+080.80
sep2006_dec134.92e+084.62e+081.071.55e+081.67e+080.93

Geomagnetic cutoff at 500 km

max vertical Rc = 15.4 GV at (7, 96); Smart & Shea grids give ~15-17 GV over SE Asia at ISS altitudes.

AP8MIN >10 MeV peak at 500 km: 4.2e+03 cm^-2 s^-1 at (-35, -54).

Orbit-averaged integral fluxes (cm^-2 s^-1), phi=600 MV, Kp=2, AP8/AE8 MIN, quiet Sun

orbitp>10 trappedp>10 GCRp>100 totale>1 trappedHe>10/n GCRFe>10/n GCRn>1 albedoγ 10keV-10MeV
ISS 400 km 51.6°29.60.5048.73050.07550.0002410.28532.7
SSO 800 km 98.6°2921.111003.17e+030.1410.0004260.42436.7
MEO/GPS 20200 km 55°02.942.919.38e+050.3410.0009920.021143.9
GEO 75°W03.022.972.69e+050.3450.001010.0053944.1
interplanetary 1 AU03.042.9900.3480.00101044.1

Albedo neutrons (cm^-2 s^-1): model vs measurements

measurementconditionsmeasuredOGO-6-anchored model (default)Kole 2015 as published
OGO-6 1-10 MeV (Jenkins+1971) - fit anchorRc<=0.3 GV, 19690.280.2790.311
OGO-6 1-10 MeV (Jenkins+1971) - fit anchorRc>=12 GV, 19690.0350.03490.0108
Salyut-6 thermal-~5 MeVmag. equator, 350 km, 1975-800.060.06080.0167
Salyut-6 thermal-~5 MeV45 deg0.430.3220.0474
Salyut-6 thermal-~5 MeV60 deg0.580.6390.593
Balloon leakage, thermal-20 MeV (PRL 20, 1048, 1968)42 deg, solar min0.360.3370.0684
OGO-6 total leakage 10 eV-5 MeVlambda=0, 19690.080.05450.018
OGO-6 total leakage 10 eV-5 MeVlambda=70, 19690.80.5370.519

Oxygen at ~1 AU, 1975-77 (phi = 516 MV): GCR+ACR model vs HELIOS E6 (cm^-2 s^-1 sr^-1 (MeV/n)^-1)

bin (MeV/n)HELIOSmodel GCRmodel ACRmodel totalnote
9-133.88e-061.37e-073.74e-063.88e-06ACR fit anchor
13-288.11e-072.35e-075.76e-078.11e-07ACR fit anchor
21-483.15e-073.52e-079.3e-084.45e-07independent
52-834.54e-075.44e-075.8e-095.5e-07independent (GCR only)

ACR solar-cycle factor vs phi: 400 MV: 1, 516 MV: 1, 650 MV: 0.215, 800 MV: 0.0427, 950 MV: 0.00937, 1100 MV: 0.00224

LEO trapped protons >10 MeV, orbit average (cm^-2 s^-1), AP8MIN native field

orbitAP8 rawx Armstrong & Colborn (2000)modern-field AP8 (not recommended)
ISS 400 km 51.615.529.674
HST 540 km 28.548.896.4153
SSO 800 km 98.6151292248

Solar-flare neutrons, 1982 June 3 (Chupp 1990 emission spectrum, decay in flight)

quantitymodelreference
fluence >50 MeV at 1 AU (cm^-2)245~270 (Dunphy et al., as reported in Chupp 1998: 1991 Jun 11 limit <27 cm^-2 is ">10x less than 1982 Jun 3")
survival of 10 MeV neutrons to 1 AU0.021"only a few percent" (Muraki group review)
emission >50 MeV (sr^-1)1.69e+29~2.2e29 (same source)

Flare gamma-ray lines and hard X-rays (peak flux at 1 AU)

GOES classF35 (ph cm^-2 s^-1 keV^-1)photon index2.223 MeV (ph cm^-2 s^-1)0.511 MeVnuclear de-excitation total
M10.4933.291.23e-064.01e-083.11e-06
X17.892.300.001290.0001940.00326
X554.92.300.1660.07290.42
X17.22432.306.946.9117.5

Check: 2003 Oct 28 (X17.2) total 2.223 MeV fluence measured by INTEGRAL/SPI ~1400 ph cm^-2 (Kiener et al. 2006); the model peak flux x ~10-20 min gives ~4167-8333, i.e. x3-6 high but within the ~x10 scatter of the line-flux vs GOES relation.

Trapped ACR oxygen at L = 2, ~600 km (cm^-2 s^-1 sr^-1 (MeV/n)^-1)

phi (MV)model at 20 MeV/nSAMPEX/MAST 1992-98 (Leske et al. 1999, 26th ICRC, Fig. 1)
4504.26e-051e-5 to 1e-4 (rising toward the 1996-97 minimum)
5502.86e-051e-5 to 1e-4 (rising toward the 1996-97 minimum)
7005.28e-061e-5 to 1e-4 (rising toward the 1996-97 minimum)

Jovian electrons at 1 AU (e- m^-2 s^-1 sr^-1 MeV^-1, synodic average)

E (MeV)Jovian modelgalactic, this package (force field, phi 500)note
13503.09e-06normalization (350 at 1 MeV)
347.21.82e-05
103.150.000158
200.3510.000564
300.06260.00117

The force-field galactic electron intensity below ~100 MeV is far below the drift-diffusion models (~4 at 1 MeV, Nndanganeni & Potgieter 2018): Jovian electrons dominate 1-25 MeV either way.

GCR dose behind aluminum (Geant4 response matrices) vs MSL/RAD cruise 2011-12

phi = 577 MV (Usoskin, Dec 2011 - Jul 2012), r = 1.2 AU. RAD (Zeitlin et al. 2013; Guo et al. 2015): Si 0.332 +- 0.023 mGy/day, plastic 0.461 +- 0.092 mGy/day, 1.84 +- 0.33 mSv/day. RAD sat behind a broad shielding distribution, mostly below ~10-20 g/cm^2.

Al (g/cm^2)Si (mGy/d)water (mGy/d)dose equiv. (mSv/d)
0.30.3070.3802.426.37
10.3030.3782.265.98
30.2960.3731.875.03
100.3040.3981.443.61
300.3340.4731.062.24

Charged particles: point dose (fluence x stopping power). Neutrons and photons: mean dose in a 15 cm water sphere from Geant4 coefficients. Both are included in the water columns.

ISS Columbus (DOSIS passive dosimeters, Berger et al. 2016, SWSC 6, A39) vs model behind 20-30 g/cm^2 Al

epochaltitudemeasured (uGy/day, 11 locations)model water 20 / 30 g/cm^2 (uGy/day)model dose equiv. 20 / 30 (uSv/day)model 20 / 30
2010.5 (phi 474)350 km195-270294 / 246553 / 4611.88 / 1.87
2012.5 (phi 626)400 km260-360438 / 322747 / 5431.70 / 1.69

DOSIS-1 measured = 3.3 +- 0.1 (TLD + track detectors). The model is lower, because the point-dose method leaves out target fragments made inside the body by protons. Trapped protons are anisotropic in LEO; the fold treats them as isotropic.

Proton dose in Si behind Al, Aug 1972 SEP event fluence (Gy): Geant4 fold vs straight-ahead CSDA vs SHIELDOSE-2

Al (g/cm^2)Geant4 fold, void average (all secondaries)straight-ahead CSDA, normal path (= center of a sphere, no nuclear losses)SHIELDOSE-2 solid sphere (IRBEM)
0.349.280.629.3
119.927.615.3
35.6874.69
100.5170.7890.636
300.03250.03480.0116

The fold gives the average over the inside of the shell. There, oblique paths through the wall reduce the dose to ~0.6-0.8 of the center value for these steep spectra, so it should sit below the straight-ahead column, and it does. SHIELDOSE-2 through IRBEM comes out below both at thin depths. We have not resolved this; it looks like a normalization convention.

(SEP in fluence mode, so "Gy/s" columns are event totals in Gy.)

Provenance

Generated by engine/validation/run_validation.py with spacerad 0.1.0, numpy 2.5.5, scipy 1.18.1, SpacePy 0.7.0. Do not edit this file by hand: change the script or the engine and regenerate.

Page status: draft, updated 2026-11-16. radiation.space 0.1.0 (e1a50c428882).
These are estimates for learning and early trade studies. They are not a substitute for a mission radiation analysis, and nothing here is medical advice.
Developed and hosted by Such Software.