Accuracy of model components
Method, independent comparison and expected accuracy of each model component.
Components
| Component | Method | Checked against | Expect |
|---|---|---|---|
| Galactic cosmic-ray protons | Force-field modulation of the Vos & Potgieter (2015) local interstellar spectrum, with the modulation potential φ on the Usoskin et al. (2017) scale. | AMS-02 proton flux, 2011 to 2013. | Within 10 % above 3 GV. 12 to 35 % high at 1 to 3 GV with the neutron-monitor φ; within 10 % if φ is refit to 670 MV. |
| Galactic cosmic-ray nuclei, Z = 2 to 28 | Force-field modulation of the Badhwar-O'Neill 2014 local interstellar spectra. | HELIOS oxygen at 52 to 83 MeV/n. | About 20 % high. |
| Cosmic rays against distance from the Sun | φ falls linearly with distance, calibrated to a 2.7 %/AU proton gradient at 1.7 GV. | Fine from 0.3 to 5 AU, coarse beyond. | |
| Anomalous cosmic rays | Oxygen fitted to HELIOS, 1975 to 1977; other elements by fixed ratios; intensity as the neutron-monitor rate to the 25th power; radial gradients of 49, 35, 13 and 4 %/AU. | The factor of about 500 between solar minimum and maximum in CREME96. | A factor 2 at solar minimum, 3 near maximum. The shape below 9 MeV/n is assumed. |
| Solar energetic particles | Band-function fits to the fluence of ground-level events; August 1972 from tabulated fluences; peak flux by scaling to the GOES peak above 10 MeV; heavy ions by gradual-event abundances. | GOES fluences above 10 and 30 MeV. | A factor 0.7 to 1.4 on fluence. Peak spectra ignore how the spectrum evolves during an event. |
| Trapped protons and electrons | AP8 and AE8 through IRBEM on their native field epochs, with the South Atlantic Anomaly drifted 0.3° per year; low-orbit protons above 15 MeV doubled. | The flight data compiled by Armstrong & Colborn (2000), ±25 %. | ±25 % above 15 MeV below 2000 km. A factor 2 to 3 below 15 MeV and in medium Earth orbit. |
| Trapped anomalous cosmic rays | One hundred times the interplanetary anomalous oxygen in a shell at L = 2 ± 0.12; nitrogen and neon at half their interplanetary ratios. | SAMPEX, 1992 to 1998. | A factor 3. The dependence on altitude and field strength is assumed. |
| Geomagnetic cutoff | Størmer cutoff, 14.5 GV / L², on IGRF McIlwain L; shifted 0.75° of latitude per Kp step; open above L = 5. | Smart & Shea trajectory-traced grids. | 10 to 20 % in cutoff rigidity. |
| Albedo neutrons | Kole et al. (2015) spectral shape; cutoff and solar-cycle dependence from a cosmic-ray yield integral fitted to OGO-6; averaged over the visible disk; inverse-square from 100 km. | Salyut-6, a balloon flight and the OGO-6 total leakage flux. | Within about 25 % of Salyut-6 and the balloon flight; about a third below the OGO-6 total leakage flux. |
| Albedo photons and charged secondaries | Formulas of Sazonov, Churazov, Mizuno and Abdo as compiled by Cumani et al. (2019). | A factor 2. The charged secondaries are the low-latitude set. | |
| Cosmic X-ray and gamma-ray background | The analytic fit of Gruber et al. (1999). | INTEGRAL and Swift-BAT, which sit 8 to 10 % higher. | About 10 %. |
| The quiet Sun and flare soft X-rays | A 5772 K blackbody scaled to 1361 W/m²; flares as an isothermal continuum with the temperature set by the GOES class. | Infrared and visible only for the quiet Sun. A factor 2 below 10 keV for flares. | |
| Flare hard X-rays | A power law at peak, with the flux at 35 keV and the index from the GOES class. | A factor 3. Measured from 15 to 100 keV and extrapolated to 10 MeV. | |
| Flare gamma-ray lines | The 2.223 MeV line from the GOES class; the 0.511 MeV line from the 2.223 MeV line; de-excitation lines as 2.223 / 0.4, split by Solar Maximum Mission averages. | The INTEGRAL/SPI fluence of 2003 October 28. | A factor 3 to 10 for any one flare. |
| Solar-flare neutrons | The Chupp (1990) emission spectrum of 1982 June 3, times 0.93 for 2003 October 28, with decay in flight. | The fluence above 50 MeV of 1982 June 3. | A factor 2 for these two events. Other flares are unknown. |
| Jovian electrons | 350 E⁻¹·⁶³ exp(−(E − 1)/9.4) electrons m⁻² s⁻¹ sr⁻¹ MeV⁻¹ at 1 AU, with a 13-month magnetic connection computed from the planets' positions. | The ISEE-3 spectral shape. | A factor 2 to 3 on average, with swings of a factor 10. |
| Solar wind and geostationary plasma | ECSS mean solar wind, falling as r⁻²; the ECSS worst-case bi-Maxwellian at geostationary orbit. | Typical values for the wind; a design worst case at geostationary orbit. | |
| Shielding | Geant4 11.4.1 with the QBBC physics list: a spherical aluminum shell under isotropic irradiation, 0.3 to 30 g/cm². | The MSL/RAD cruise dose, and SHIELDOSE-2 for protons. | See the validation results. |
| Dose from the Geant4 fold | Charged-particle fluence times stopping power, with the ICRP 60 quality factor; neutrons and photons as the mean dose in a water sphere of 15 cm radius. | MSL/RAD in cruise and the DOSIS dosimeters on the ISS. | A factor 2 to 3. The mean quality factor is low because target fragments made inside the body are left out. |
| Dose against depth (Python engine only) | SHIELDOSE-2 for electrons, bremsstrahlung and protons. | No heavy ions or neutrons, so deep-shielding cosmic-ray dose is underestimated. |
Interpretation of "Expect"
- Percentage: agreement with independent measurements over the stated range.
- Factor: the true value may lie that factor above or below the estimate. A factor of 3 spans nearly an order of magnitude.
- Assumed: a value chosen by this project without a supporting measurement.
- No entry under "Checked against": no comparison with data independent of the fit.
Comparisons are tabulated in validation; methods and sources are given on the component pages.
Reference and browser implementations
The models are implemented twice: a Python reference engine, compared with measurements, and a JavaScript port that runs in the browser. The port is tested against the reference engine to 5 % in free space and 6 % behind a wall. Precomputed tables describes the inputs the browser cannot compute.